Class ADisplacementCruiser/Racer

Comet 45

Comar · Andrea Vallicelli · 2003

Updated

The Comet 45 is a 13.72 m displacement racing yacht designed by Andrea Vallicelli and built by Comar, first launched in 2003. It races in Class A. Across the measured fleet it goes better than its own numbers promise, ahead of 29% of the designs it races against. It is at its best in light air and struggles to hold that once it blows.

Comet 45 - Andrea Vallicelli - ComarP 17.18 mLOA 13.72 m
Race Edge29Proven in racing

Goes better than its own measurements promise, and does it better than 29% of the boats it races against.

33rd of 46 in its class.

Under 10 kn
42
10–16 kn
4
Over 16 kn
16

This design has been found in real race results — 136 starts across 73 events — not only in measurement files.

Length

13.72 m

45′ 0″

Beam

4.21 m

Draft

2.70 m

Displacement

10.1 t

Sail area

114 m²

On the podium

Where a Comet 45 finishes when she goes racing.

On the podium

24%

of 136 starts by 20 boats

Wins

7%

Wins7%9
Seconds8%11
Thirds9%12
Off the podium76%104

Read from 136 starts by 20 boats between 2010 and 2026, counting races with six boats or more.

Recent regattas

The latest events where a Comet 45 was on the start line, named as the organisers publish them.

  • ItalyArgentario Winter Series2026
  • ItalyCampionato Invernale dell'Argentario - Coastal Race2026
  • ItalyCampionato Invernale West Liguria2026
  • ItalyCampionato della Lanterna2026
  • ItalyRound Aeolian Race 2026 - Campionato Italiano Offshore ORC2026

Raced one we are missing?

Report a regatta

Round the buoys, or offshore

A short windward-leeward and a night at sea ask different things of a boat. Here is how this one does in each.

Round the buoys

32%

of these races end on the podium

38 races of 10 NM or less

Offshore & coastal

19%

of these races end on the podium

91 races over 10 NM

Sharper round the buoys. Short courses reward acceleration and manoeuvring, and that is where this design makes its money.

Comet 45s racing

Every Comet 45 with results on TackRegatta, the boats with the most wins first.

Who she races against

The designs a Comet 45 actually lines up with, most often first. The bar shows how those meetings ended.

This design aheadRival ahead
Grand Soleil 40 (Paperini)59%ahead in 41 of 69 meetings, 51 races
Comet 4152%ahead in 35 of 67 meetings, 42 racestoo close to call
First 40.767%ahead in 39 of 58 meetings, 41 races
First 34.758%ahead in 22 of 38 meetings, 34 races
X-3544%ahead in 15 of 34 meetings, 31 races
Sun Fast 360078%ahead in 25 of 32 meetings, 29 races
First 36.762%ahead in 33 of 53 meetings, 29 races
X-4136%ahead in 12 of 33 meetings, 28 races
First 35 (Farr)68%ahead in 23 of 34 meetings, 27 races
First 4050%ahead in 13 of 26 meetings, 24 racestoo close to call
J/12231%ahead in 8 of 26 meetings, 24 races
Grand Soleil 44 (Polli)54%ahead in 19 of 35 meetings, 23 races
Sly 4271%ahead in 20 of 28 meetings, 22 races
Swan 4212%ahead in 3 of 24 meetings, 21 racesalmost always behind
Swan 4518%ahead in 5 of 28 meetings, 20 racesalmost always behind
Farr 4052%ahead in 11 of 21 meetings, 19 racestoo close to call
Bolt 3758%ahead in 11 of 19 meetings, 19 races
Comet 38 (Vallicelli)52%ahead in 11 of 21 meetings, 18 racestoo close to call
First 44.756%ahead in 14 of 25 meetings, 17 races
Elan 33376%ahead in 16 of 21 meetings, 16 races
Grand Soleil 46 (Carkeek)61%ahead in 11 of 18 meetings, 16 races
Grand Soleil 40 (Polli)38%ahead in 6 of 16 meetings, 16 races
Dufour 4039%ahead in 9 of 23 meetings, 15 races
Elan 34073%ahead in 11 of 15 meetings, 15 races
Grand Soleil 43 (Carkeek)78%ahead in 14 of 18 meetings, 15 races
Dufour 3467%ahead in 12 of 18 meetings, 15 races
Grand Soleil 43 (Maletto)27%ahead in 4 of 15 meetings, 14 races
Cookson 5047%ahead in 8 of 17 meetings, 14 racestoo close to call
Comet 5182%ahead in 14 of 17 meetings, 14 racesalmost always ahead
Este 3993%ahead in 13 of 14 meetings, 14 races
M 3753%ahead in 8 of 15 meetings, 13 races
X-33259%ahead in 13 of 22 meetings, 13 races
Grand Soleil 37 (Carkeek)55%ahead in 12 of 22 meetings, 13 races
Canard 4138%ahead in 6 of 16 meetings, 13 races
First 31.792%ahead in 12 of 13 meetings, 13 races
Rimar 44.385%ahead in 11 of 13 meetings, 12 races
X-44268%ahead in 13 of 19 meetings, 12 races
Elan 31067%ahead in 8 of 12 meetings, 12 races
Italia 11.987%ahead in 2 of 30 meetings, 11 racesalmost always behind
Bonin 3191%ahead in 10 of 11 meetings, 11 races

Some of the boats it races against

How the Comet 45 has fared against each of them, boat against boat on corrected time. Ordered by how often the two meet, not by who wins.

Comet 45 vs Grand Soleil 40 (Paperini)ahead 59% of 69 head-to-heads
Comet 45 vs Comet 41ahead 52% of 67 head-to-heads
Comet 45 vs First 40.7ahead 67% of 58 head-to-heads
Comet 45 vs First 36.7ahead 62% of 53 head-to-heads
Comet 45 vs First 34.7ahead 58% of 38 head-to-heads

Speed at every angle

The shape of this design's speed, drawn from the measured fleet. Pick a wind and watch it stretch.

36930°60°90°120°150°WIND10.6

Upwind VMG

5.87

38°

Beam reach

9.38

90°

Broad reach

10.58

135°

Downwind VMG

8.56

170°

Speed in knots at 20 knots of true wind. Green marks the angles that pay: the closest useful beat and the deepest run worth sailing.

Where it wins and where it pays

Every boat is judged against its own measurements — length, weight, sail area. The quicker those say it should be, the more it has to deliver just to break even. Going fast is not enough: it has to go faster than its own numbers promised.

There is no obvious weak spot here. It rewards preparation and crew work more than it rewards picking the right day.

Where it gains

Its best ground is across the wind once the breeze fills, where it goes better than its measurements say it should.

Where it pays

It falls short running deep in a strong breeze, giving away time it never gets back. That is a displacement hull working to its designed speed.

Above the line it delivers more than promised and gains on the fleet. Below, it falls short. Move the wind: plenty of boats sit on one side in the light and the other when it blows.

True wind
Upwind+0.10 kn
Beam reach+0.21 kn
Broad reach+0.17 kn
Downwind+0.10 kn

Full width is 0.4 kn either way.

At 10 knots this design makes back more than its rating asks on the beam reach.

How fast is a Comet 45

Boat speed in knots, by true wind angle and wind strength.

Angle6 kn10 kn14 kn20 kn
Beat VMG3.855.255.725.87
52°5.887.638.108.28
60°6.217.878.338.53
75°6.458.068.628.97
90°6.408.098.759.38
110°6.378.339.139.82
120°6.198.259.1910.28
135°5.567.848.9110.58
150°4.666.988.369.67
Run VMG4.036.057.348.56

How they are set up

The range each sail spans across the fleet.

Mainsail53 m² – 69 m²
Headsail45 m² – 64 m²
Gennaker127 m² – 182 m²
Spinnaker144 m² – 158 m²

Roughly half carry a folding propeller. Crew weight is declared around 690 kg.

Rigging

Comet 45 rig and sail dimensions

A Comet 45 carries 17.20 m of mainsail hoist on a 5.95 m boom, a forestay 17.95 m above the deck and a 6.52 m bowsprit. Typical figures across the 18 boats measured under the current VPP, with the range each one spans.

Rig

Mainsail hoistP17.20 m16.30 – 18.35
Boom lengthE5.95 m5.60 – 6.22
Forestay heightIG17.95 m17.30 – 18.63
Fore triangle baseJ5.70 m5.65 – 5.73
Spinnaker hoistISP18.28 m17.40 – 20.45
BowspritTPS6.52 m5.70 – 7.06
Boom above deckBAS1.81 m1.73 – 2.30

Sails

Mainsail59.7 m²52.8 – 68.7
Headsail54.1 m²44.7 – 64.3
Gennaker158.6 m²126.7 – 182.0
Spinnaker154.1 m²144.3 – 157.8

The spinnaker spreads widest of all — 127 to 182 m² depending on bowsprit and set-up. Before ordering a sail, read the figure on your own measurement record rather than the typical one for the design.